.png)
Subscribers are worth 3x more than one-time buyers. Most CPG brands know this — yet most of their customers still choose a one-time purchase at checkout.
We've built 200+ stores for some of the fastest-growing brands on Shopify. Subscriptions is one of the hottest topics with any of the brands we work with that have replenishable products and it's one of the most consistently under-optimised parts of the store.
In most cases, the gap between a one-time purchase and a subscription doesn't come down to price. It comes down to what's visible in the buy box and how it's presented.
Here are the five things that you can do to improve your subscription rate.
further in depth reading
This is a collection of articles that will provide you with more information about our FREE email marketing course.
1. Make Subscriptions the Default
The simplest change you can make is setting up the subscription option as the default choice for customers. Use visual hierarchy (highlighted card, filled radio button, colored badge) to make it the obvious choice.
Default selections matter because most customers take the path of least resistance — they land on the page, see what's selected, and click Add to Cart.
Neuro Gum does this well. Their Subscribe & Save card is pre-selected, highlighted in teal, and shows the discounted price ($27.65) with the percentage saved (21% OFF) alongside the full one-time price ($35.00).
2. Stack Benefits, Not Just a Discount
A percentage off is a good starting point, but it's not always enough to incentivize customers to switch to a subscription. For shoppers who aren't particularly price-sensitive, adding tangible perks that are exclusive to subscribers increases the perceived value. Things like free gifts, bonuses, free shipping, or early access.
The Absorption Company subscribe card lists three distinct things:
- 25% off today
- Free shipping ($7 value) and ability to cancel/pause
- Free gifts valued at $70
3. Answer the Cancellation Question Up Front
One of the most common reasons shoppers pick one-time over subscribe is uncertainty about what happens after they commit. Can they cancel? Is it easy? Will they get charged?
Most stores address this somewhere in the fine print. The more effective approach is to answer it directly inside the subscribe card, where the decision is actually being made.
Old School Labs includes "Pause, update, or cancel anytime" as one of their subscribe card bullet points.
4. Introduce the Subscription Offer Before the Product Page
Most subscription brands only mention subscription value on the PDP. But by the time a customer gets there, they may already have a one-time mindset.
Introduce subscription value at every earlier touchpoint — announcement bar, homepage, collection page, and product cards. Prime the expectation before the buy box.
Gainful uses their announcement bar saying, "Save 25% when you subscribe". Seems like a small addition. But it primes customers as soon as they hit your store.
5. Surface the Subscription Option in the Cart
When a shopper adds the one-time version of a product to their cart, that's not necessarily a lost subscription. The cart drawer is a good place to present the option again.
Neuro Gum does this showing a "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 21%" button directly below the line item. One tap converts the item to a subscription. They also call out that subscriptions get free shipping.
The bottom line
Not all five of these will apply to every store. But most buy boxes or carts we look at are missing at least a few of them.
The default selection is usually the quickest thing to address. It's one setting, and it applies to every product page visit from that point forward.
The rest compounds from there. Each additional subscriber you convert on the first purchase is revenue you don't have to earn a second time.
If you'd like us to optimize your subscription setup, grab time with the team and get a free audit.
— The Platter Team
Visit the Platter website here and follow the Author Ben Sharf on LinkedIn
